By Jorge Padilla, CFP®
If you’ve owned investment property for a long time, selling it is rarely a simple decision. The property has probably grown in value, and part of you may be ready to move on. But a sale usually comes with a tax bill, and that bill can take a real bite out of the capital you were counting on for whatever comes next.
A 1031 exchange is one way to keep more of that capital working. Under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code, you can sell real property held for business or investment and reinvest in other qualifying real property, deferring the capital gain tax in the process. In practice, that usually means trading one property for another: an apartment building for a retail center, say, or a rental house for farmland.
What many owners don’t realize is that the next property doesn’t have to be one you manage yourself.
What an exchange does and doesn’t do
A 1031 exchange defers the tax. It doesn’t erase it. Your gain, and your original cost basis, carry over into the replacement property, including any depreciation you’ve claimed along the way. Some investors exchange several times over a lifetime, and under current law, heirs who inherit property generally receive a stepped-up cost basis, which can reduce or eliminate the deferred gain. Your tax advisor can tell you how that plays out for your situation.
A few ground rules apply. Both properties must be held for business or investment, so a personal residence or second home doesn’t qualify. The same taxpayer generally needs to be on both sides of the exchange, so if an LLC or trust sells, that same entity buys. And to defer all of the gain, the replacement property generally needs to be worth at least as much as what you sold, with any debt you pay off replaced. Cash or other value you take out along the way, known as “boot,” may be taxable.
Why you can’t touch the money
This is the step that surprises people most.
In a typical exchange, you can’t receive the sale proceeds, even for a day. If the money lands in your bank account, or you have the right to take it, the IRS can treat the transaction as an ordinary sale, and the gain becomes taxable. That’s true even if you meant to reinvest every dollar.
To prevent that, investors use a Qualified Intermediary, often called a QI. The QI is brought in before the sale closes, under a written exchange agreement. At closing, the proceeds go to the QI, who holds them in a separate escrow account and uses them to buy the replacement property for you. The QI generally can’t be someone who has acted as your agent in the past two years, such as your attorney, accountant, or real estate agent.
Because your sale proceeds will sit with the QI for weeks or months, it’s reasonable to ask about their experience, how client funds are protected, and what happens if something goes wrong. And the timing matters: the QI account needs to be in place before closing, not after.
If you don’t want another rental
Maybe you’re tired of tenants, repairs, and insurance claims, or you’re managing a property from another state. Maybe one building has quietly grown into a large share of your net worth. Or maybe you’re nearing retirement and don’t want the next ten years to look like the last ten.
Selling outright can trigger a large tax bill. Buying another property yourself can defer the gain, but it often brings the same responsibilities back. For some investors, professionally managed real estate is worth a look as a replacement. Two structures come up most often.
A Delaware Statutory Trust, or DST, is a trust that owns one or more institutional-quality properties, such as apartment communities, industrial buildings, or medical offices. You buy a fractional interest, and under IRS guidance, interests in a properly structured DST qualify as replacement property. Investors tend to like them for a few practical reasons. Some hold a portfolio of properties, so you’re less tied to any single building or tenant. The sponsor handles the management and reporting, so the income is passive. You can often size your investment to match your exchange, which can help avoid boot. And because the sponsor has already done the underwriting and financing, some DSTs can close quickly, which helps when the 45-day and 180-day clocks are running. The trade-offs are real, too. DSTs are generally open only to accredited investors, you have little say in decisions like when the property is sold, and your money is usually tied up for years.
Some sponsors take it a step further with what’s called a 1031 UPREIT program. You first complete a 1031 exchange into a DST created by a real estate investment trust (REIT). Later, often after a couple of years, the REIT may offer to swap your DST interest for units in its operating partnership, in a second tax-deferred transaction under Section 721. If that happens, you own a piece of a larger, more diversified portfolio, may be able to redeem units for cash after a holding period, and your heirs may receive a stepped-up basis. While the REIT isn’t required to make that offer, the large majority of times this conversion happens smoothly.
Both approaches are complicated, and the details of each offering matter a great deal. Neither is right for everyone.
It’s still an investment
Professional management takes work off your plate. It doesn’t take risk off the table. These investments can carry fees, limited liquidity, real estate market risk, and risk tied to the sponsor. Many are illiquid, with expected holding periods of several years, and some use debt, which can magnify losses. Distributions aren’t guaranteed, and you give up the control you had as a direct owner.
So the question we find most useful isn’t “which property should I buy?” It’s “what do I want my real estate wealth to do for me from here?”
Watch the clock, especially late in the year
In a typical deferred exchange, you have 45 days from the sale to identify replacement property in writing, and 180 days to complete the purchase, or until your tax return due date if that comes first. Both clocks start at the same time, and they generally can’t be extended, even when a deadline lands on a weekend or holiday.
When you identify properties, the most common approach lets you name up to three, whatever their value, or more than three as long as their combined value stays within 200% of what you sold.
That “tax return due date” language matters most when a sale happens in the fall or winter. A closing in November or December can shorten your 180 days unless you file an extension, so if you’re thinking about selling before year end, bring your tax advisor in early.
Either way, 45 days goes by fast. It’s hard to evaluate options well once a property has already sold, which is why the best time to talk is before you accept a contract to sell the property.
Fitting the exchange into the rest of your life
How much of your wealth is already in real estate? How much do you need to keep liquid outside the exchange? What income do you want from the replacement investment, and how does it sit alongside everything else you own? What role should real estate play in your life five or ten years from now?
Those are planning questions, not real estate questions. At Meira Wealth, we’ve helped clients evaluate 1031 exchanges involving institutionally managed real estate as part of a broader conversation, and we work through it alongside your CPA and attorney. We look at the exchange next to your investments, your income needs, your taxes, and what you hope to leave to your family.
Questions to ask before you sell
Do I want to stay an active owner, or move toward something more passive?
Is my property eligible? A personal residence or second home generally isn’t.
What is my adjusted cost basis? If it’s close to the expected sale price, there may be little gain to defer.
Who will be my Qualified Intermediary, and will the exchange agreement be signed before closing?
What happens, tax-wise, if the exchange is only partly completed or doesn’t close?
How much of my net worth would be tied up in the replacement investment, and for how long?
How does this fit with my estate plan and what I want to leave to my family?
If you own appreciated investment property and you’re thinking about selling, give us a call before you list it. That’s when we can be the most helpful.
This material is for informational purposes only and is not intended as individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Tax rules are complex and subject to change. Investments in real estate, Delaware Statutory Trusts, and REIT operating partnerships involve risks, including illiquidity, the possible loss of principal, and the risk that tax treatment is not achieved. Such investments are generally available only to accredited investors and may not be suitable for everyone. There is no guarantee that any strategy will achieve its objectives. Please consult with a qualified tax and legal professional regarding your individual situation.
Share: